Hablamos español · Говорим по-русски · ქართულად
(917) 476-7666EN·ES·RU·KA·UZ

Traffic Violations

Disobeying a Traffic Device

Charged with disobeying a traffic device under NY VTL § 1110(a)? The Law Office of Anthony Sharnov, PC handles these tickets in the DMV Traffic Violations Bureau and local courts across New York.

Overview

What you need to know about Disobeying a Traffic Device.

The basics, what we do, and the issues we see most.

How many points is disobeying a traffic device in New York?

Quick Answer

Disobeying a traffic-control device under New York VTL § 1110(a) adds 2 points to your license as a general moving violation, or 3 points when the device is a traffic signal, stop sign, or yield sign charged under VTL § 1111, § 1172, or § 1142. There is no jail; the fine runs up to $150 for a first offense, plus a state surcharge of roughly $88 to $93. Reach 6 points in 18 months and the DMV adds a Driver Responsibility Assessment of $100 a year for three years. Eleven points in 24 months can suspend your license.

Services we offer for Disobeying a Traffic Device.

We defend disobeyed-traffic-device tickets in New York's TVB and local traffic courts. Here is what handling your case involves:

  • Read the ticket and the officer's notes to check whether the device, the location, and the alleged conduct are described with enough specificity to support a § 1110(a) conviction
  • Examine whether the sign or signal was lawfully placed, in working order, and free of graffiti, foliage, or obstruction at the moment you passed it
  • Cross-examine the issuing officer at a TVB hearing about sight lines, distance, traffic, and weather conditions
  • Argue for dismissal where the prosecution cannot establish each element by clear and convincing evidence
  • In local courts that allow negotiation, work toward a reduced charge that carries fewer points or zero points
  • Appear at the hearing on your behalf where the court permits attorney appearance, so you may avoid taking a day off work
  • Check your current DMV point total so a plea on this ticket does not trigger a suspension or a Driver Responsibility Assessment

Scenarios we see most.

  • A stop sign or signal hidden by tree branches, a parked truck, or a temporary obstruction
  • Faded, graffiti-covered, mispositioned, or knocked-down signs that were not clearly legible
  • Confusion at a malfunctioning, dark, or newly changed traffic signal
  • Out-of-state and rental drivers unsure how a New York conviction transfers to their home-state license
  • Commercial drivers (CDL holders) who face separate federal and employer consequences for a moving violation
  • Drivers already near the 11-point, 24-month suspension threshold who cannot absorb another conviction
  • TVB tickets where no plea bargaining is available, unlike upstate and suburban local courts

Who we help

Who we represent.

Every case handled directly by the attorney you speak with at intake.

Everyday Drivers

Speeding and moving violations that add points and raise insurance costs.

Commercial (CDL) Drivers

Violations that can threaten a commercial license and a driver’s livelihood.

Suspended or Revoked Licenses

Aggravated unlicensed operation, reinstatement, and accumulated points.

Out-of-Area Drivers

Tickets received while traveling through NYC, Long Island, or Upstate New York.

How we handle your case

From summons to resolution.

The same attorney handles your matter from intake through hearing and closeout.

  1. 1

    Step 1 of 5

    Free case review

  2. 2

    Step 2 of 5

    Plead not guilty and request a hearing

  3. 3

    Step 3 of 5

    Gather evidence and officer notes

  4. 4

    Step 4 of 5

    Hearing or negotiation

  5. 5

    Step 5 of 5

    Resolution and DMV follow-up

Frequently asked

Questions clients ask first.

Direct answers from the attorney who handles these matters.

Most asked

Is disobeying a traffic device the same as a red-light ticket?

Not exactly. VTL § 1110(a) is the broad catch-all for failing to obey any traffic-control device and is scored as a 2-point moving violation. A red light has its own section, VTL § 1111, which carries 3 points, and a stop sign (§ 1172) or yield sign (§ 1142) is also 3 points. Separately, a red-light or speed CAMERA ticket is a civil penalty issued to the vehicle's owner — it carries no points and no driver conviction.

Question 2

Do I have to appear in court myself?

It depends on where the ticket is returnable. For a non-criminal infraction heard at the DMV Traffic Violations Bureau in New York City and several other regions, an attorney can often appear and handle the hearing for you. In upstate and suburban local traffic courts the practice varies, and the court may ask you to appear or to authorize your attorney to appear. We confirm the rule for your specific court before your date.

Question 3

Will this ticket affect my insurance?

A points conviction can show up on your driving record and may be considered by your insurer at renewal; that decision is the insurance company's, not the court's. We do not control what an insurer does. What we can do is contest the charge or, where the facts and court allow, work toward a reduction that keeps points off your record in the first place.

Free case review

Got a Disobeying-a-Traffic-Device Ticket?

Talk with The Law Office of Anthony Sharnov, PC before you pay the fine — paying the ticket is a guilty plea that puts points on your record. Call 917-476-7666 for a review of your ticket.

Or email us

info@sharnovlaw.com

An attorney reads every message.

  • Same-day response

    During business hours

  • Direct attorney access

    Same lawyer from intake to close

  • Transparent pricing

    Fees quoted up front